Teen in 2021 Capital High Student Killing Ordered Back to Prison to Serve 11-Year Sentence
A teenager convicted in connection with the 2021 killing of a Capital High School student has been ordered back to prison after violating the terms of his probation, reigniting attention on the tragic case and its legal aftermath.
Crishawn Coller, now 19, was originally charged as a juvenile before his case was transferred to adult court. At age 16, he pleaded guilty to involuntary manslaughter and two counts of wanton endangerment following the fatal shooting of 14-year-old Da’nija Miller in Kanawha County, West Virginia.
Background of the 2021 Shooting
The incident occurred in August 2021 at a residence in the Rutledge area. Prosecutors stated that while there was insufficient evidence to prove intent, Coller handled a firearm in a reckless and dangerous manner, leading to Miller’s death.
Initial Sentencing and Youthful Offender Program
In June 2023, Circuit Court Judge Maryclaire Akers imposed the maximum sentence under the plea agreement—11 years in total. However, after turning 18, Coller was resentenced under state law and placed in a youthful offender program. Upon successfully completing the program, he was released on five years of probation.
Probation Violations Lead to Prison Return
Coller’s probation was short-lived. Authorities reported multiple violations following a routine drug screening. A subsequent search of his cell phones revealed videos and images showing firearms, drugs, and cash.
According to testimony, some footage showed Coller handling weapons, including an AR-style rifle, and mimicking shooting gestures toward others. Despite defense claims that the videos could have been altered or AI-generated, Coller reportedly admitted he was the individual in the recordings.
Court Decision and Sentencing
During the hearing, prosecutors emphasized the severity of the violations and the continued risk posed by Coller’s behavior. The court ultimately ruled to revoke his probation.
Judge Akers reinstated the original 11-year sentence, ordering Coller to serve the remainder of his term in prison.
Ongoing Impact
The case continues to resonate in the community, particularly as it highlights concerns about youth violence, firearm safety, and the effectiveness of rehabilitation programs. Prosecutors noted the painful reality that Miller would have been 19 years old this year—a reminder of the life lost too soon.